NPE error but it cuts off before telling me why

Code:

    private void offlinecomparer(Player p, String offline1, Player args) {
        p.sendMessage("p1 iss offline");
        int wins = plugin.stats.getInt(offline1 + ".wins");
        int fails = plugin.stats.getInt(offline1 + ".fails");
        int losses = plugin.stats.getInt(offline1 + ".losses");
        String name = plugin.player.getString(offline1 + ".name");
        UUID uuid = args.getUniqueId();
        int wins1 = plugin.stats.getInt(uuid + ".wins");
        int fails1 = plugin.stats.getInt(uuid + ".fails");
        int losses1 = plugin.stats.getInt(uuid + ".losses");
        String name1 = plugin.player.getString(uuid + ".name");
        p.sendMessage("Wins is " + wins1);
        p.sendMessage("fails is " + fails1);
        p.sendMessage("name is " + name1);
        p.sendMessage("loss is " + losses1);
        List<String> comparestats = plugin.getConfig().getStringList("comparestats");
        for (String s : comparestats) {
            p.sendMessage(ChatColor.translateAlternateColorCodes('&', s).replaceAll("%player%", name)
                    .replaceAll("%wins%", String.valueOf(wins))
                    .replaceAll("%fails%", String.valueOf(fails))
                    .replaceAll("%losses%", String.valueOf(losses))
                    .replaceAll("%player1%", name1)
                    .replaceAll("%wins1%", String.valueOf(wins1))
                    .replaceAll("%fails1%", String.valueOf(fails1))
                    .replaceAll("%losses%", String.valueOf(losses1))
                    .replace("%Compare%", plugin.getConfig().getString("offlinevar"))
                    .replace("%compare%", plugin.getConfig().getString("offlinevar")));
        }
    }

I know its big... but thats beside the point.

I've got 2 comparers atm 1 of them is just as long but working.
This 1 cuts off as soon as it needs to sent a msg for Player "args".
The p.sendmessage at the top is filled and processed with all the info needed.
For some reason however on replacing all that data in this 1 it fails to do so.

Again, Console won't tell me why, it cuts off right after it shows NullPointerException

 

first : "p1 is offline" not iss
second : you worked with the offline players name ->

but the same way with the online players uuid ->

are there both (uuid and name possible [are both in the config])?